From the Blog
New Homes Now Run Cheaper Per Square Foot in San Antonio: The $156 vs. $164 Story
Zillow's 2026 research put the median new home in San Antonio at about $156 per square foot and the median resale at about $164, making new construction roughly 4% to 5% cheaper per square foot than existing homes, one of the biggest new-home discounts in the country. New construction also makes up 37.1% of metro home sales over the past 12 months, the highest share of any U.S. market. Those two numbers are changing how San Antonio buyers should compare a builder home with a resale, and the honest answer is not as simple as either price tag. Here is the breakdown.
Zillow's 2026 research put the median new home in San Antonio at about $156 per square foot and the median resale at about $164, making new construction roughly 4% to 5% cheaper per square foot than existing homes, one of the biggest new-home discounts in the country. New construction also makes up 37.1% of metro home sales over the past 12 months, the highest share of any U.S. market. Those two numbers are changing how San Antonio buyers should compare a builder home with a resale, and the honest answer is not as simple as either price tag. Here is the breakdown.
San Antonio Builders Are Getting Desperate… Here's What Buyers Can Get Right Now More videos are on my channel .
The per-square-foot flip, in numbers
Zillow's median figures for July 2026 show new homes at about $156 per square foot and existing homes at about $164, a gap of roughly 4% to 5% in new construction's favor. That flips the old assumption that new costs more per square foot than resale. Two honest caveats: new homes tend to be larger and sit in newer suburbs, and on total sticker price builders still run higher, around $335,000 versus about $295,000 for resale, roughly 14% more. The per-square-foot discount is real, and the total-price gap is real too. Both matter.
Per-square-foot figures are medians, not quotes on a specific home. Your comparison should use the finished price per square foot including lot premium, upgraded finishes, and the incentive package.
Why builders can undercut resale right now
Builders are largely holding their list prices while competing through incentives: rate buydowns, closing-cost credits of 3% to 5%, and flex cash. Resale sellers are the ones cutting prices as their homes sit longer, with Bexar County resale inventory up about 15% year over year by late 2026. Combined with surplus spec inventory, that lets builders price new homes aggressively per square foot and still protect their margins through financing. It also means the builder's advertised price is rarely the final price; the incentive sheet is part of the price.
Where the resale discount really shows up
In a market where the median price is flat and homes average 88 days on market, resale sellers are more negotiable than they have been in years, which is its own form of discount. The buyer who compares a finished new home at $156 per square foot against a resale that closed at 91.8% of its list price has two different kinds of leverage. The new home discounts its financing; the resale discounts its price. The winning move is to compute both on the same monthly payment.
The honest trade-offs at the same budget
At a $350,000 budget, the decision is usually about what a community gives you, not just the structure. New construction brings a 1-2-10 warranty, modern floor plans, and energy systems, but also HOA dues and MUD taxes that vary wildly by community. Resale brings established trees, built-out neighborhoods, and a price that already reflects its location, plus condition and systems that an inspection can verify before you commit.
- Add HOA and MUD costs to the new-home monthly payment before comparing.
- Read the warranty schedule and the warranty company's reputation, not just the builder's.
- For resale, get the inspection and the last three months of solds on the street.
How to compare a builder quote with a resale
Ask the builder for the fully loaded price per square foot: base home, lot premium, structural options, and finishes, minus the incentive package. Then put the resale through the same math, including its closing costs and the repairs an inspection will likely surface. San Antonio's new-home share, the highest in the country at 37.1% of sales, means builders are competing hard here, and that competition is leverage you should use.
Frequently asked questions
Is new construction really cheaper than resale in San Antonio?
Per square foot, yes, right now: about $156 for new versus $164 for resale per Zillow's July 2026 medians, before incentives. On total price, new homes still run higher, so compare finished cost per square foot, plus HOA, MUD, and the incentive package.
Why are San Antonio builders offering big incentives?
New construction is 37.1% of metro sales, the highest share in the country, and builders hold standing inventory. With resale inventory up about 15%, builders compete on financing: rate buydowns, closing-cost credits, and flex cash, while holding their list prices.
Written by Phyllis Domingo
REALTOR® · TX License 745926 · 100+ homes sold · Helping families move well in San Antonio and the Hill Country since long before the hard part became normal.
Have a question about this topic?
Every family's situation is different. Send me a note and I will respond personally, usually within a business day.